Loading blog content, please wait...
Buying Your First Investment Property in Franklin If you have been thinking about buying your first rental or investment property in Franklin, this is t...
If you have been thinking about buying your first rental or investment property in Franklin, this is the walk-through you have been looking for. We will cover how to think about your budget, where to look, what kind of property makes sense to start with, and the numbers that actually matter. This is for the first-timer, not the seasoned flipper.
The mistake most first-time investors make is falling in love with a property before they understand what they can truly afford to carry. An investment property is a different animal than a home you live in. Lenders usually want a bigger down payment, often 20 to 25 percent, and the interest rate tends to run higher than what you would get on a primary residence.
So start by talking to a lender who does investment loans, not just standard mortgages. Ask them plainly: with my income and credit, what would the monthly payment look like at Franklin prices, and how much cash do I need at closing? Then look at your own reserves. You want money left over after the purchase, because vacancies happen, water heaters die, and tenants move out. A property with zero cushion behind it is a stressful property.
If you are self-employed or your income is uneven, gather two years of tax returns before you even call a lender. It saves everyone a round of back-and-forth.
For most people starting out in Franklin, a single-family home or a small townhome makes the cleanest first investment. It is easier to finance, easier to rent, and easier to sell later if your plans change. Duplexes and small multifamily buildings can be great, but they are harder to find here and usually come with more moving parts than a beginner wants to juggle in year one.
Be realistic about condition, too. A move-in-ready home in a solid neighborhood will rent faster and cause you fewer headaches than a cheaper fixer that eats your weekends and your savings. There is a place for renovation projects, but that place is usually not your very first deal. Learn the rhythm of being a landlord on an easy property before you take on a hard one.
Franklin is one of the most desirable places to live in Middle Tennessee, and that reputation is priced in. Homes near downtown, around historic Main Street and the areas close to it, tend to carry premium prices, which means the rent has to be high to make the math work. That does not make them bad investments, it just changes the strategy toward long-term appreciation rather than strong monthly cash flow.
If you want a better balance between purchase price and rental income, look a little farther out. Neighborhoods and newer developments toward the edges of the city and out along the growth corridors often give you more house for the money, and they attract steady renters who work in Franklin, Cool Springs, or commute up to Nashville. Proximity to good schools, to the interstate, and to the Cool Springs employment and shopping hub all drive rental demand. A house near strong schools rents itself, even when you do not want it to.
The point is to match the neighborhood to your goal. Cash flow now, or value later. Both are fine. Just be clear about which one you are chasing before you make an offer.
Here is where new investors get burned. They look at rent minus mortgage, see a positive number, and call it profit. It is not.
Your real expenses include the mortgage, property taxes, insurance, and then the ones people forget: repairs and maintenance, vacancy (the weeks the place sits empty between tenants), property management if you are not handling it yourself, and money set aside for big-ticket items like a roof or HVAC. A common rough approach is to assume a chunk of your rent, often a quarter to a third of it, will go toward these ongoing costs over time. Build that in from the start.
When you subtract all of that from the rent and there is still something left over, you have real cash flow. If the number is thin or negative, you are betting entirely on the property going up in value, and that is a bet you should make on purpose, not by accident.
Before you buy, it is also worth understanding how rental income is taxed and what you can deduct, because depreciation and expense write-offs meaningfully change your returns. The IRS guide to residential rental property lays out what counts as income, what you can deduct, and how depreciation works.
You have two honest options. Manage it yourself, or hire a property manager. There is no wrong answer, but there is a wrong answer for your life.
Managing it yourself saves you the management fee, usually a percentage of the monthly rent. But you become the person who takes the call when the toilet overflows at eleven at night, screens the applicants, handles the lease, and chases the late payment. If you live near the property, have some handyman instinct, and want to learn the business hands-on, doing it yourself in year one teaches you more than any book.
If you are a busy professional, an out-of-state investor, or you just do not want to be on call, a property manager earns their fee by handling tenants, maintenance, and the legal details that trip people up. This is a big part of what we do at Redbird, and we would rather be straight with you: if the numbers only work when you skip management and do it all yourself, factor that reality in before you buy, not after.
Your first property is where you learn the whole cycle. Buying, financing, screening a tenant, handling a repair, filing the taxes, and eventually deciding whether to hold or sell. Buy one solid property in a neighborhood you understand, run it well for a year, and you will know far more about your next deal than any amount of reading could teach you.
When you are ready to look, or you just want someone local to sanity-check the numbers on a place you found, that is exactly the kind of conversation we like having. No pressure, just a straight answer about whether the deal makes sense.